Why voyager is better than ds9

To their credit, the creators of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine never let their in-house status as the least important Star Trek series deter them from telling great, thrilling stories. DS9 's Captain Benjamin Sisko remains one of the most interesting, complicated leads in all of Star Trek , and the Dominion War arc set the tone for how innumerable 21st-century science fiction shows would handle their long-term storylines.

The show has found new life in the streaming era and has been routinely reassessed as the best, most consistent Star Trek series of all time. Not too bad of a fate for a show that very few people at the top believed in when it was still in production.

Dusty Stowe has been writing for Screen Rant since A native of Yorktown, Virginia, he moved to Los Angeles in to pursue a career in the entertainment industry. BillJ , Sep 1, Amusingly I can't tell whether that's intended to be worst-best or best-worst. Joined: Sep 28, Location: Orbiting Urectum. DS9 beat VOY in stories, characters, development and overall feel.

They had great arcs, plenty of storylines that crossed each season and were revisited, rich and interesting main characters and brilliant recurring ones too. VOY had some good moments but it never hit what it could've been, it never had a sense of isolation and desperation that a ship lost 70 years from home would have had, whilst the premise itself kinda demands the need for some sense of serialisation. Add to that some wishy-washy characters who didn't really go anywhere and the fact that most were ignored for a pair of bionic boobs in the matter half of the show.

Joined: Mar 4, Location: U. Voyager remains my favorite. Although I like all of the series. Any Star Trek is better than no Star Trek. I never really got into DS9 first run thanks to the network that was showing it butchering the schedule.

I missed huge chunks of the ongoing arcs thanks to sports preemptions all of the time. TNG is good, despite the first two seasons looking bad from today's standards. The stories still hold true. ENT's first two seasons were mediocre at best, the last two were pretty sweet. But I have a soft spot for VOY. It was showing when I was going through high school and I really looked forward to watching it week after week. It was the Trek I grew up with and it aired at a time when spoilers were pretty much nonexistent for me.

I did not know of any behind the scenes stuff. Improve this question. Mark Rogers Borror0 Borror0 2, 2 2 gold badges 19 19 silver badges 20 20 bronze badges. However: Perhaps you should reconsider watching DS9 first. Of the two, it is by far the better in overall quality. I have a confession: I actually much prefer Voyager to DS9. Let the public shaming begin. DS9 is great Clearly, casting Patrick Stewart as the Enterprise-D captain has ruined us all for lesser actors.

DS9 defeats the whole purpose of ST; there is no exploring. It's largely a cantina stop with way too many episodes devoted to Ferengi shiftiness. Show 1 more comment. Active Oldest Votes. In the first aspect, you should be able to jump right into Voyager. Improve this answer. Could you be a little more specific than "first few seasons of Voyager"?

After season 3? After season 4? The show needed a few seasons to find its footing, but it eventually flourished — even under some stifling rules. The galactic union of peaceful planets, of which Earth is a member, has essentially no crime, no want, no conflict, no suffering.

The crew of the Enterprise are essentially ideal post-modern humans. The universe was still rich enough, and the cast talented enough, to deliver some terrific hours of television. But it all seemed, well, dare I say, boring? The characters of TNG populated a world I might wish for my children, but would probably snooze through myself. The writers and producers knew it was a problem, too. When DS9 was approved, it was intended, from the start, to be different.

The characters would be less perfect — a station commander with unresolved emotional issues stemming from the tragic death of his wife, a first officer with a dark past during a guerrilla war against brutal alien occupiers, a human doctor with a shameful secret.

The setting was notably grittier: an isolated outpost above a planet devastated by a brutal war and decades-long genocide of the native inhabitants.

It was a hugely refreshing change of pace, and you can tell the writers who transferred over from TNG were delighted by the opportunity to stretch their creative legs a bit. At the time, I was delighted. It was a far more realistic take on the future than what TNG had given us. DS9 was Star Trek for grown ups. TNG, as great as it was, looked naively dopey by comparison to its cousin.

Deep Space Nine wrapped up its run in